Advertisement

Researchers demonstrate $10,000 Apple Pay theft from a locked iPhone

Researchers demonstrate $10,000 Apple Pay theft from a locked iPhone

TL;DR

  • Veritasium demonstrated a $10,000 charge from YouTuber Marques Brownlee’s locked iPhone using an NFC relay attack.
  • The exploit targets only iPhones with a Visa card set as the Express Transit card and does not affect Mastercard, Amex, or Android devices.
  • The vulnerability was first published in 2021, and Apple and Visa have not issued a fix, each pointing to the other as responsible.
  • Users can eliminate the risk by removing their Visa Express Transit card in Settings > Wallet & Apple Pay > Express Transit Card > None.

Popular science YouTube channel Veritasium published a video last month showing a $10,000 contactless payment processed from tech creator Marques Brownlee’s iPhone. Brownlee did not touch the device, unlock it, or authorize anything.

The phone was face down, screen off, and entirely unattended when the charge went through.

The demonstration was staged under controlled conditions, with Brownlee’s consent and knowledge.

Veritasium worked with the researchers who first discovered the vulnerability, Professors Ioana Boureanu of the University of Surrey and Tom Chothia of the University of Birmingham, to reproduce the attack for the camera.

How the attack works

The exploit chains two distinct weaknesses together. The first is Apple’s Express Transit feature, which allows an iPhone to pay at subway turnstiles and bus readers without requiring Face ID or a passcode. The phone detects a transit terminal signal and automatically authorizes payment.

The second weakness is in how Visa processes transit-mode transactions: it does not apply the same transaction limits or fraud screening to transit payments as to standard purchases.

An attacker needs a custom NFC card reader tuned to broadcast the same terminal identifier used by legitimate transit systems. That reader is connected to a laptop. When held near the target iPhone, it intercepts the Express Transit handshake and relays the transaction data to a burner Android phone, which then taps a legitimate payment terminal elsewhere.

The iPhone authorises what it believes is a routine transit tap. Visa approves the charge without applying standard fraud checks. The attacker receives the funds.

The technique is classified as a man-in-the-middle attack. The NFC reader must be in close physical proximity to the target device, and the transaction relay must complete before the phone’s session times out. The equipment involved, a custom NFC reader, a laptop, and a rooted Android phone acting as a card emulator, is not something a casual opportunist carries through a shopping mall.

67364 141782 Apple Pay 2

The attack only works under a specific combination of conditions. The target must have an iPhone, and a Visa card must be set as the Express Transit card in Apple Wallet. The attacker must get the NFC reader within range of the device, meaning physical proximity and not a remote wireless attack.

Also Read: Identity attacks now drive most break-ins, and attackers move fast

The vulnerability does not affect Android users in any configuration. It does not work with Mastercard or American Express cards, because those networks use different authentication protocols for transit payments. It does not trigger if the user has no Express Transit card set, or if the card set is not a Visa product. Samsung Pay uses a separate payment architecture and is not susceptible.

Professors Boureanu and Chothia originally published their findings in 2021. The vulnerability has been publicly known for five years. No documented case of the exploit being used in a real theft has been reported.

Apple and Visa’s positions

Apple told Veritasium that the issue lies with Visa’s payment system, not with iPhone hardware or software. Visa told Veritasium the attack is unlikely to occur at scale in real-world conditions and pointed to its existing fraud dispute process as the mechanism for resolving any transaction the cardholder did not authorize.

The University of Birmingham researchers noted in 2021 that when two industry parties each hold partial responsibility for a vulnerability, neither tends to move first to fix it. That dynamic has held for five years.

Visa told Veritasium that contactless fraud across all in-person transactions amounts to roughly two cents per $100 spent. The company frames that figure as evidence the risk is contained.

Critics of that position note that a cardholder who wakes up to a $10,000 unauthorized charge still absorbs the disruption, the dispute process, and the wait for a refund, even if the money eventually comes back.

What to do

The most direct action available to iPhone users is to remove the Visa Express Transit card from the dedicated slot in Apple Wallet. The setting is at Settings, then Wallet & Apple Pay, then Express Transit Card, then None. Apple enables Express Transit automatically when a compatible card is added, so users who have never specifically configured this may still have it active.

Users who rely on Express Transit for daily commuting and do not want to lose that convenience can instead swap the Express Transit card slot to a Mastercard or Amex, as those cards are not affected by this specific vulnerability.

Users who only have Visa cards, or who do not use transit payments regularly, lose nothing practical by disabling Express Transit entirely. The feature’s primary benefit, paying at turnstiles on a dead battery, is useful only in specific circumstances that can be planned around.

Muchiri Avatar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *